Philo Reads

The internet has always been strange. But in the last decade, it has also become dangerous. Anonymous forums like 4chan and 8kun, originally built for irreverent humor and edgy memes, have incubated subcultures of nihilism, despair, and authoritarian politics.

This isn’t just fringe culture anymore. What began as “jokes” in meme threads has spilled over into real-world politics, shaping everything from white nationalist rallies to presidential campaigns. To understand how this happened, we need to look at the symbols, language, and myths that turned disaffected young men into online radicals.

Pepe the Frog: From Harmless Meme to Hate Symbol

No figure illustrates this better than Pepe the Frog. Created by cartoonist Matt Furie in 2005 for his comic Boy’s Club, Pepe was a chill, harmless frog with the catchphrase “Feels good man.” By the early 2010s, Pepe was everywhere on 4chan. Users remixed him endlessly: sad Pepe, smug Pepe, rare Pepe. He was a blank slate for whatever emotion or inside joke a user wanted to express.

But during the 2016 election, Pepe became something else entirely. The alt-right dressed him up in Nazi uniforms, Klan robes, or as Donald Trump himself. Some users posted him in gas chambers with anti-Semitic captions. Others called themselves “the Pepe Army” online.

The strategy was deliberate: using irony and humor to sneak extremist messages into mainstream spaces. “It’s just a meme, bro” became the defense but behind the laughter was real ideology. In 2016, the Anti-Defamation League officially listed Pepe as a hate symbol.

The Blackpill: Nihilism Disguised as Truth

This dark humor fed into what extremists call the blackpill. Borrowing from The Matrix’s redpill imagery, the blackpill represents not “awakening” but despair: the belief that society is beyond repair, democracy is a sham, and collapse is inevitable.

Online, blackpill culture often overlaps with:

Incels (Involuntary Celibates): A subculture of men who believe feminism has ruined society, that women are shallow and unattainable, and that their romantic failures prove life is meaningless. Memes of “doomer” Wojaks: sad, hollow-eyed cartoon men, often illustrate this worldview.
Accelerationists: Those who want to speed up societal collapse, believing chaos will open the door to authoritarian renewal. Pepe in military gear or slogans like “embrace collapse” circulate in these spaces.
Groypers: A far-right group led by Nick Fuentes, represented by a smirking, chubby frog meme (a cousin of Pepe). They specialize in mixing Christian imagery with white nationalism, especially targeting young conservatives under the guise of “traditional values.”

The blackpill unites these groups in despair. Life is hopeless, they say, so cruelty is justified. And since collapse is inevitable, authoritarianism is the only answer.

The Kali Yuga: Ancient Myth Repackaged for Fascism

Layered onto this despair is the appropriation of the Hindu concept of the Kali Yuga. In Hindu cosmology, the Kali Yuga is an age of decline, corruption, and chaos before renewal. But on far-right forums, it is weaponized as proof that the West is in irreversible decay, corrupted by feminism, multiculturalism, or democracy itself.

The alt-right even designed “Kali Yuga Pepe” memes, Pepe dressed as a Hindu god, declaring that we live in the darkest age and only strong rulers can set things right. For some, the myth becomes an excuse for authoritarianism: “Yes, the world is collapsing, but that’s why we need Trump, or a king, or a dictator.”

Why This Subculture Attracts So Many Men, Even Christian Men

The far-right internet subculture thrives on alienation. It draws in men who feel overlooked, powerless, or betrayed by the world around them. For many, online forums become places to vent frustrations without judgment, to feel a sense of belonging, and to find meaning in an otherwise confusing and chaotic world. Several dynamics are at play:

Loneliness and Isolation. Many men who end up on 4chan, incel boards, or Groypers’ livestreams are socially isolated. They lack deep friendships, strong mentors, or healthy community. The anonymous boards give them an instant “tribe,” even if it’s toxic.
Identity Crisis. In a society where traditional markers of masculinity (stable work, marriage, fatherhood) feel out of reach, these men crave clear identities. Far-right memes offer them simplistic roles: the warrior against “degeneracy,” the defender of “tradition,” or the victim of feminism and multiculturalism.
The Appeal of Power. When someone feels powerless, nihilism can be perversely comforting. The blackpill and Kali Yuga myth tell men: “You are powerless because the world is corrupted.” But then the ideology offers a solution: strength, domination, authoritarianism. It’s a counterfeit gospel of power.
Irony as a Shield. Men in these spaces can say cruel or hateful things while pretending it’s “just a joke.” This allows them to try on extremism without feeling guilty or responsible. Over time, though, the irony becomes sincerity.
A Hollowed-Out Christianity. Many who enter these spaces call themselves Christian, but often their faith is cultural, not discipling. They grew up with Christian identity but without robust theology, deep community, or spiritual formation. Far-right culture then offers them a “warrior Christianity”, a distorted faith centered on defending civilization rather than following Christ. Slogans like “Christ is King” are plastered over Pepe memes, not to proclaim the Gospel, but to baptize nationalism and authoritarianism.

This is why so many self-proclaimed Christian men are drawn into these circles: they are spiritually hungry, but instead of being fed by the Church with the Bread of Life, they are consuming junk food memes that promise belonging, power, and purpose.

From Irony to Trumpism

The irony-heavy culture of 4chan primed young people for Trump’s rise. They didn’t flock to him because of policy papers or detailed platforms. They flocked to him because he embodied chaos. Trump was the “meme candidate,” someone who mocked institutions, insulted opponents, and blurred the line between reality and performance.

Pepe memes flooded social media during his 2016 campaign. Slogans like “Make America Great Again” were reframed as a kind of anti-modern crusade against the supposed decay of the Kali Yuga. In Trump, blackpilled nihilists found a figure who promised both destruction and renewal.

The blending of irony, despair, and authoritarian longing created a toxic spiritual ecosystem. Forums radicalized young men not with manifestos at first, but with jokes, memes, and symbols. And once immersed in this culture, they were discipled into a politics of cruelty.

A Better Way for Christian Men

If far-right subcultures attract men by offering belonging, identity, and power, the Church must not ignore those same longings. The difference is that the Gospel meets them truthfully, while internet extremism meets them with distortion and despair.

Belonging in Christ’s Body.
Online forums provide a counterfeit community built on irony and cruelty. But the Church offers true fellowship, brothers and sisters who share life together, break bread together, and bear one another’s burdens (Acts 2:42–47; Galatians 6:2). Christian men do not need anonymous threads for belonging; they need brothers in Christ who will know them, challenge them, and love them.
Identity in Christ.
The far right tells men they are victims, warriors, or defenders of “tradition.” But Scripture gives a deeper identity: adopted sons of God (Romans 8:15), co-heirs with Christ (Romans 8:17), ambassadors of reconciliation (2 Corinthians 5:20). True masculinity is not posturing online, it is living faithfully as men remade in the image of Christ.
Power in Weakness.
Extremist subcultures glorify domination, cruelty, and authoritarian strength. But the Gospel flips this upside down: “My power is made perfect in weakness” (2 Corinthians 12:9). Christian men find strength not in crushing enemies but in sacrificial service, love of neighbor, and courage rooted in the cross.
Joy Instead of Cynicism.
Memes thrive on mockery and despair. But the kingdom of God is characterized by joy, peace, and righteousness in the Holy Spirit (Romans 14:17). Laughter isn’t sinful, but laughter that tears down and despairs is hollow. Christian men are called to a deeper joy: the kind that comes from knowing the resurrection is real.
A Mission Worth Living For.
The alt-right promises men a “cause”: to save civilization, to fight decline, to wage culture war. But this is a false mission. Christ has already given his people the true mission: to make disciples of all nations, to love God and love neighbor, to bear witness to his coming kingdom. That’s a calling infinitely greater than defending memes and idols of power.

For men shaped by these online subcultures, the answer is not simply to “stop scrolling” or “touch grass.” The answer is a radical reorientation of identity, belonging, and mission in Jesus Christ. The Gospel is not another pill to swallow: red, black, or otherwise. It is new life.

A Christian Response: Hope Against Despair

For Christians, this poses both a challenge and a calling. The far right’s meme-driven nihilism is more than internet noise, it is a counterfeit religion. It offers a diagnosis (the world is corrupt), a myth (the Kali Yuga or blackpill), and a savior figure (Trump or authoritarian strongmen). It is eschatology without resurrection.

The Church must counter this false discipleship with the true Gospel:

Hope instead of despair. The blackpill proclaims collapse. But Christ has risen, and God is making all things new (Revelation 21:5).
Community instead of isolation. Anonymous forums prey on loneliness. The Church offers embodied belonging, where people are known and loved (Galatians 6:2).
Truth instead of distortion. Conspiracies and memes twist reality. Christians are called to speak truth in love (Ephesians 4:25).
Justice instead of cruelty. Far-right humor celebrates dehumanization. But Christ identifies with “the least of these” (Matthew 25:40) and calls us to justice, mercy, and humility (Micah 6:8).

Christians must also be aware that the battle is cultural as well as spiritual. Memes, slogans, and symbols matter. If Pepe the Frog could be twisted into a fascist icon, then the Church must work creatively to embody symbols of joy, resurrection, and solidarity that point beyond despair to Christ.

The far right thrives on the claim that nothing matters, everything is ruined, and cruelty is the only truth. But Christians know the deeper truth: that history is not spiraling into endless ruin, but is being drawn toward renewal by the God who raised Jesus from the dead.

That’s the story we need to tell, and the life we need to live, in a world still drowning in memes of despair.

Menu